Which brings us to the second amazing thing. Tim lets his inner middle schooler out to giggle about the "wooly balls" Kristin was using in her outfit. When she asked him if she should use regular balls or the wooly balls, he said, "I prefer the wooly balls," and promptly turned bright red. Tim rarely drops his concerned father character. For anyone else this moment would have been awkward, but with Tim it was just plain funny.
A not so fun part of the episode was the revelation that Gretchen is really annoying. Sure, the editing made it worse, but she shouldn't give advice to everyone and tell people to keep their workstations neat and tidy. No one likes that. Also, it's best not to sound like a know-it-all after winning the first two challenges. Gretchen, stay quiet and be a talented designer so all of us at home can cheer you on.
Back to amazing things--Betsey Johnson was the guest judge! How perfect! Party store clothes + Betsey Johnson = Love!
The winner of this challenge received immunity. Also, Heidi announced that the losing model would be eliminated with the losing designer. Gretchen had a chance to switch up models, but didn't take it so we didn't get to see if Gretchen would be able to steal models and leave a designer to choose between the losing designer's models or if all of them would get to switch. It seems they are stuck with who they have for now.
Speaking of models, they brought the designers little gift bags during their fittings. But they were far from gifts. Instead, they were full of party store goodies that had to be used to create an accessory for each designers look.
Christopher's dress was quite simple, but the fact that it was made out of napkins and little sparkly pieces was rather creative. It looked like fabric and moved nicely. (The color looked much better on TV).
Michael Drummond had a futuristic Alice in Wonderland thing going on. The skirt looked a little clunky on the runway, but I liked his vision for this.
Ivy's dress was very pretty. It could have used some color and maybe a belt, but it moved nicely. Also, I love seeing wearable skirt lengths.
Michael Costello accomplished a crazy amount of work in a day's time. His dress had great movement. It was also bold and colorful. He captured the challenge quite well. I was surprised he didn't find himself in the top three. He must have been fourth.
Peach's design sensibility just doesn't resonate with me. It all looks too much like the junior's clothing sold when I was in high school. This skirt is cute, but it looks like gift bags and tissue paper. She didn't transform anything. It was nice, but nothing more.
The top of Mondo's two-tone pink dress reminded me of the cup dress Daniel Feld made on season 5. Mondo's had even more detail. The structured top with the super poofy skirt was fun. I also love that he used color, which was in short supply during a challenge that should have been brighter.
Kristin used color, embodied the fun spirit of the challenge and used several different materials. However, it looked cheap. I could see a dollar store Barbie doll knock-off wearing it. I thought she was in danger, but she made it to safety thanks to some worse designs.
April made glitter and party supplies very edgy. (A little too edgy since it was stabbing her model in the face during fittings). It looked very cool and not at all like it came from a party store.
Gretchen found herself in the top three again. I wasn't as crazy about this look, but I do give Gretchen credit for making separates. The idea of turning paper bags into a faux-leather jacket was also pretty brilliant. After the judges tore apart McKell for styling, I don't feel like these boots should have been allowed to accompany the rest of the look into the top three. It doesn't work. It's hard to see her accessory here, but she made a cuff out of black balloons and ribbon. It's also hard to see the chevron print she cut into the skirt's two-layered fringe. The judges imagined Kate Moss wearing this, which I can totally see.
Valerie made a chic dress out of black and white napkins. The judges praised it. They also praised her for taking her styling tips from last week and applying them here. Betsey Johnson thought it would be a great party dress since you'd already have napkins on hands if you spill anything. Valerie had a great attitude about coming so close to a win once again. She admitted the winning dress was more innovative and seemed happy enough to be in the top three. I'm liking her personality more and more. Her confessionals are quite cute and funny.
Andy nabbed the win. He braided and shaped a ton of ribbon to create a really unique dress. He nearly ran out of time but Peach and April helped him after they finished their dresses. I especially loved his accessory, which was a little glove made from black balloons. I'm thrilled to see Andy win since I've liked his work a lot so far, and he used a lot of fascinating techniques to make this. Michael Kors predicted Heidi and Rihanna would fight over wear it. Heidi called dibs since she saw it first. Betsey Johnson actually thought it was too beautiful, which Andy decided was a rather nice compliment.
A.J. should have had this challenge in the bag with his Heatherette-inspired dream to dress Paris Hitlon. Instead, he froze and ended up with a pinata that exploded (according to Michael Kors). This is the designer who auditioned with dresses that included Rubber Duckies, but he lost it all here somehow. Betsey Johnson saw some promise but would have liked to see it "a zillion times exploded." She's right. If you're going to do a beaded fringe crotch you have to really go for it. Hopefully he can pull himself together because he's made it to next week.
Sadly, Casanova has also made it to next week. He did OK last week, but this week was mess with too much going on including puzzling ruffled legs. He used table clothes even though Tim warned him not to. He also still needs a translator because he's clearly spacey enough without a language barrier making it worse. Michael Kors said, "She looks like a transvestite flamenco dancer at a funeral." I'm assuming Casanova got to stay so Michael Kors can keep saying things like that.
And Sarah went home because the judges always vote against boring and sad when they can have crazy and over the top instead. I'm sad to see Sarah go. I think she had potential. She stopped following her instincts and got off track with this dress, but the judges never questioned her taste or understanding of the challenge. In the end the judges said they had to choose between boring and safe or a parade float. They apparently plan to attend funeral parade for transvestite flamenco dancers this week.
What did you think of this challenge? How did Betsey do as a judge? Will PETA be after Casanova for his brutal murder of Plush Puppies and use of (very)faux-fur? Who were your favorites and least favorites? Who is out next week? Do we have any guess for Bryant Park yet? (I'm starting to think Andy, Gretchen and Valerie). Or is it too soon?
Check back Tuesday for an interview with McKell Maddox!