becca hates them. Turtlenecks make her feel choked and claustrophobic. I can't live without thin turtlenecks for layering in the cold weather. Remember when we didn't wear scarves all the time? We wore turtlenecks. Perhaps the prevalence of scarves is part of why turtlenecks aren't being sold in droves this season. Scarves at least gives you the option of adjusting the tightness.